5 Things You Must Know When Hiring A Nanny

For the working mama, finding the right childcare arrangement can be the most stressful part of becoming a mother. Especially in regards to hiring a nanny, where do you start?

But first, let’s set the stage. You’re pregnant AF, weeks (or days) away from producing your very first human, the hormones are raging, and hey—by the way, start figuring out who you’re going to give your unborn baby to in just a few short weeks.

[ReviewDisclaimer]

After I had Lils and left my full-time job in digital marketing, I thought I would be diving head-first into that SAHM life. Childcare wasn’t even a consideration. But at 6 weeks postpartum, my former agency presented me with an opportunity to work part-time! And while excited for the opportunity, I realized I only had a couple of weeks to figure out my next move for childcare.

When deciding on childcare, you have a couple options: 1.) traditional full-time daycare (part-time is a rare find for infants,) 2.) in-home care, 3.) family or friends, or 4.) a nanny or au pair.

And with each of those options you also have to reflect on your priorities.

First and foremost, what makes the most sense, financially? Does your budget limit or expand your options? Do you need full-time or part-time? What flexibility do you require? How do you prioritize socialization? How about a schedule and structure? Do you have multiple children?

But mostly… WHAT IS LIFE I AM NOT EVEN WORKING YET AND ALREADY MISS MY BABY!?!?

(See why this process might be intimidating?)

For our family, we knew having my newborn at home, under the care of an experienced nanny, (part-time,) was going to be the best fit.

So, if like me, you’re leaning towards finding your own personal Mary Poppins to meet your childcare needs, here are the 5 things you must know when hiring a nanny:

finding-a-nanny

1.) Where to look –

A.) Start inside your inner circle – Whether it be through family, friends, church, or even your social network, you’d be surprised by the amount of people who “know somebody who knows somebody” looking for a nanny position. And wouldn’t you inherently trust someone more if they were vouched for by someone you also know and trust?

B.) If that fails, try Care.com I’ll be the first to say I thought Care.com was the Craigslist of childcare. And not to be totally morbid, but the first day my nanny, Beth, was on the job, I thought I was going to come home to find my baby chopped up and hidden in the walls of our home.

DISCLAIMER: 1.) Lils is in one piece. 2.) Beth is aware of this story. 3.) She also has a funny story about me. (SUBSCRIBE TO OUR EMAILS at the end of this post and you can read all about it!!) 4.) Beth is nothing short of an angel sent from nanny heaven.

But I digress. Care.com made it incredibly easy to search for qualified childcare professionals and proved that it was nothing short of the LinkedIn for childcare; not Craigslist.

 

2.) How to look

If you’re a working mom, you’ve obviously been interviewed before. But unless you’re in recruiting or management, how often have you been the interviewer?

Care.com was actually a great resource in supplying the right questions to ask but your job doesn’t stop there. Remember to request background checks, ask for references, and don’t feel bad scrutinizing those resumes.

True story: I automatically disqualified potential candidates if there were typos in their resume. If you can’t run spellcheck, you can’t watch my kid. Truth hurts, life is hard. (Isn’t that right, #keepinitrealmom, Shelley?)

[amazon_link asins=’B079ZYZVBM,B01HTWIX2S,B07C8HLWTQ,B01N40NR8P’ template=’ProductCarousel’ store=’poms2moms-20′ marketplace=’US’ link_id=’9954b0a7-4c57-11e8-9282-5d17b910beb8′]

3.) Financials –

A.) Pay – You need to understand the market value and going rate of a nanny—and that you get what you pay for. Full-time and part-time will make a difference in hourly rate. Again, this has to make sense within your budget but something to consider is that if you have multiples, a nanny might actually make more sense financially, then say, daycare.

B.) Extra Hours – What happens if either of you is running late? Or what if you request care, say in the evenings, for a date night? Is nighttime baby-sitting even a consideration for your potential nanny? You need to think about all of the possible times/ways you might want help from your nanny, to avoid confusion in the long-run.

C.) Guaranteed Time – Consider what happens when you go on vacation, and you do not require your nanny’s care that week. Unless you’ve discussed this advance, the assumption will be that she is getting paid for the time you’re away. The same story applies to daycare, so you need to be prepared to budget for this expense.

D.) Sick Days/PTO – Yes, this is standard practice; even for part-time. Think about it, if your nanny is not incentivized to stay home when she is not feeling well, guess whose kids will probably end up sick as well? Even a couple of PTO days that must be used throughout the year will serve as a gesture of goodwill.

E.) Other Expenses – Paid holidays? Gas? Compensation for outings with your children? Extra car seats? Yep. These are all things you’ll want to iron out in advance. (PS – the KeyFit30 infant car seat is perfect for transitioning between multiple vehicles. Buy an extra base and you’re good to go!)

[amazon_link asins=’B071L1NG6N,B00WOPRB2Y,B000UUBRYI,B00ODZ5R7O,B00MS9VTV0,B01DPH4DMK,B017B83E7E,B0727W9ZRL,B071J9F2JZ’ template=’ProductCarousel’ store=’poms2moms-20′ marketplace=’US’ link_id=’41f45eaf-9aa7-11e8-9b6a-0b83b46b5e9c’]

 

4.) “Good fit” hiring considerations –

More than just general qualifications, (although you’ll want to check the boxes on those, too,) you and your nanny need to be on the same page about child-rearing.

Simply said, if you’re not on the same page about how you want your baby cared for while you’re gone—inclusive of sleep, food, play, education, activity, etc.—you’re going to have a bad time. Get ahead of it by writing down every detail of what you do for your little one, and be sure to convey that message to your prospective nanny during interview time. We’re big proponents of art with Miss Beth at our house:


PRO TIP: Have a “trial day” before you actually head back to work. This will give you a chance to see how things will be done while you’re away, give you a chance to (constructively) critique, and set your nanny up for success.

5.) Communication is CRUCIAL –

Like any relationship – professional or personal – you have to be transparent about your feelings and expectations. It is a part of your DNA to be high maintenance about your kids; a good nanny knows that. But as long as you can be professional and respectful in relaying those feelings, and that standard is reciprocated, you’ll end up with an invaluable addition to your family and your children’s lives.

I’ve said it 100 times, but we struck GOLD with our nanny. She’s been key to our daughters’ development and I honestly don’t know how I would have gotten through many days, without her.

Interested in hearing how a nanny goes about finding the right family? (And a hilarious revelation she had in her first few weeks at work?) CLICK ON THE PICTURE BELOW to hear directly from Beth, P2M’s Kaitlin’s super-nanny! (Subscribers, check your inbox!  It’s already there.)

finding-a-nanny

What are your tips for finding the perfect nanny for your family?

About The Author

Kaitlin

Founder & author of the parenting & lifestyle blog, Poms2Moms. Wife, girl mom, and lover of all things outdoors, food, and wine. Travel is my love language, Netflix binges… my guilty pleasure. Find me writing about toddler drama, baby’s first year, progressive parenting, and more. Cheers! – Kaitlin

23 COMMENTS

  1. Cayla | 30th Apr 18

    This is so helpful and informative! Can we clone Beth…or have her move to Charlotte? 🙂

    • Kaitlin | 30th Apr 18

      If anything, this post was validation that she’s a highly sought after lady!! 😉

  2. Veronika | 30th Apr 18

    I hadn’t thought of working out things like PTO days. Great info!

    • Kaitlin | 30th Apr 18

      Thank you! I didn’t either! That’s another reason why Care.com was such a welcomed and useful resource – tons of tips!

  3. The Mindful MD Mom | 30th Apr 18

    This is very helpful! Finding the right childcare is very important. Thanks for the tips!

    • Kaitlin | 30th Apr 18

      Exactly! Whether it’s you, family, or someone new, you can’t go back to work without feeling at ease.

  4. Brigette Collins | 30th Apr 18

    I have always been so apprehensive when it comes to getting a nanny or any outside form of help for that matter. These are all great things to think about should extra outside help come up.

    • Kaitlin | 30th Apr 18

      Same! (See the story in the post about my initial fears of leaving.) But without family super close by, it was my only option if I wanted to go back to work part-time. And it luckily ended up being an amazing experience!

  5. Jessica | 30th Apr 18

    Wow! There’s so much that goes into it! This will be great info when I decide to have children!

    • Kaitlin | 30th Apr 18

      Yes! It’s definitely overwhelming. Enjoy your freedom – physical and mental 😉 – until that time!

  6. Amber | 30th Apr 18

    I love this! I’m not a mommy but I am a nanny on Care.com and I love seeing an insight on a moms perspective as well! Thanks for the great read (:

    • Kaitlin | 30th Apr 18

      Amber, thank you! Love my Care.com nannies. 😉 I hope you’ve had a great experience with it.

  7. Samm | 30th Apr 18

    What a relief you found a good one! So happy for you and your family. I know it’s crucial to trust who is watching your LO. We went through a similar experience and it can be so stressful!

    • Kaitlin | 30th Apr 18

      Thank you Samm! It is NOT for the faint of heart. Even with family or acquaintances, there’s apprehension that they won’t do it ‘your way’ (and to be honest, no one can…) but letting your guard down to a relative stranger was definitely an enlightening experience – with a happy ending!

  8. Mary L | 30th Apr 18

    Great post! Lots of things to consider. I don’t have kids of my own yet but I always imagine I’d be quite apprehensive about hiring someone I don’t know. But it’s definitely a great option.

    • Kaitlin | 30th Apr 18

      Mary, it really can take an emotional toll! We are so fortunate it not only worked out, but that our daughters are better for it. <3

  9. Erin | 1st May 18

    We looked into a nanny here in Canada but ultimately it was more affordable and made more sense socially to out our daughters in pre School and daycare. We even interviewed for a nanny share. Now I just need a maid! Lol

    • Kaitlin | 2nd May 18

      Erin, yes! We just enrolled our daughter in two-day-a-week preschool this year because you could tell she was getting bored of mom. 😉 As for a maid, you and me both, sister.

  10. Susie Whittenberger | 1st May 18

    We have our Midwife’s daughter… I don’t know what we’re going to do when she leaves for a month this summer….

    • Kaitlin | 2nd May 18

      Oh no, Susie! The worst part is losing someone who love and trust. Perhaps she could provide you with some references before she goes?

    • Shelley | 7th May 18

      Hey Susie, you might find an awesome teacher that needs a summer job! Most schools require a background check before they can teach so at least you’ve got that going for you! I hope you find someone!

  11. Neshama | 1st May 18

    This post is right on time! I’m finishing my masters and headed into a full time position. We are stationed overseas so no family near. A nanny/caregiver is exactly what we will need!

    • Kaitlin | 7th May 18

      Neshama, congrats on completing your degree! I’m sure it’s an exciting and also stressful time. Because of the prevalence of au pairs overseas, I feel like you’re in a great market to find the right caregiver. Good luck with your hunt!

Leave A Comment